There will be some mixed reviews, yes. No flavour is for everyone and although CDPR are very good at what they do, they would never claim perfection.

Reviews in the end don't matter a jot compared to your play experience. They are good for deciding to buy the game, but if you are here, you've probably made that decision already.

The rest is a silly, "My game is better than your game!" contest. Worthless, really.